If the driver who caused your crash has no insurance—or carries too little to cover your losses—your own uninsured motorist (UM) or underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage may become important. This reusable checklist explains how to review your policy, preserve evidence, notify insurers, document injuries, and evaluate settlement communications before you make a decision. Coverage rules, deadlines, notice requirements, and arbitration procedures vary by state and policy, so treat this as practical preparation rather than state-specific legal advice.
Overview
UM coverage is generally designed for situations involving a driver who has no applicable liability insurance. It may also apply in some hit-and-run crashes, although policies and state law can require specific proof that contact occurred or that the accident was reported promptly. UIM coverage generally becomes relevant when the at-fault driver has insurance, but the available liability limits are not enough to address the injured person’s losses.
Start by separating three questions:
- What happened? Identify the collision, the responsible driver, available liability insurance, and whether the driver can be located.
- What coverage exists? Review every potentially relevant policy, including your own auto policy and policies covering household vehicles or residents, subject to the policy’s terms and state law.
- What are the losses? Track medical care, continuing symptoms, missed work, property damage, out-of-pocket expenses, and other documented effects.
Do not assume that a policy applies simply because your name appears on it. Definitions of “insured,” “occupying,” “resident relative,” “covered auto,” and “underinsured motor vehicle” can affect the analysis. Exclusions, offsets, consent-to-settle clauses, and other provisions may also matter. A car accident lawyer or personal injury attorney can help interpret the policy when the insurer disputes coverage or the potential claim is substantial.
Checklist by scenario
When the other driver has no insurance
- Obtain the crash report. Keep the report number, responding agency information, photographs, witness contacts, and any citation details. If you have not reported the crash, ask about local reporting requirements without delaying necessary medical care.
- Confirm the driver’s insurance position. Preserve letters, emails, claim numbers, and messages showing that the driver was uninsured, the policy was denied, or coverage could not be verified. Avoid relying only on a verbal statement.
- Review your declarations page. Look for UM bodily injury limits, separate or combined limits, deductibles, and listed vehicles. The declarations page is a starting point; request the full policy and endorsements.
- Give timely notice. Notify your insurer according to the policy’s instructions. Describe the basic facts accurately and keep a copy of your notice. A late notice issue can become significant, depending on the policy and applicable law.
When the other driver has insurance but not enough
- Identify the liability limits. Ask how the at-fault driver’s insurer is handling the claim and whether the available limits may be insufficient. Do not assume that an early offer reflects the full value of your losses.
- Check your UIM limits. Find the UIM bodily injury limits, any required deductible, and provisions addressing how payments from the other driver’s insurer affect your claim.
- Ask about consent to settle. Some policies require the insured to obtain permission from the UM/UIM carrier before accepting the at-fault driver’s liability settlement or releasing that driver. Request written instructions before signing a release.
- Compare the offer with documented losses. Review medical expenses, future treatment concerns, lost income, property damage, and the effect of the injury on daily activities. For a detailed review, see how to evaluate an insurance adjuster’s settlement offer.
When the crash is a hit-and-run
- Report it promptly. Follow local requirements and keep the report, incident number, and officer contact information.
- Preserve identifying evidence. Save photographs, dashcam files, nearby business or traffic-camera information, witness details, vehicle descriptions, and any physical debris. Ask potential witnesses to preserve their original recordings.
- Document contact and circumstances. Write down what you remember while it is fresh, including the direction of travel, damage pattern, road conditions, and whether another person saw the impact.
- Review the policy’s hit-and-run language. The insurer may apply particular proof requirements. Coverage can depend on facts such as physical contact, prompt reporting, and corroborating evidence.
When household coverage may be relevant
Gather declarations pages for every auto policy in your household and ask which people and vehicles are listed. Depending on the jurisdiction and policy language, coverage questions may involve a spouse, resident relative, permissive use, or a vehicle temporarily used by the injured person. Provide complete facts about where household members live and which vehicles were involved. An uninsured motorist lawyer can help assess overlapping or disputed policies, but do not conceal a policy or household relationship from an insurer.
What to double-check
- Policy documents: Obtain the declarations page, insuring agreement, definitions, exclusions, endorsements, renewal documents, and any amendments in effect on the crash date.
- Notice language: Check where and how the policy requires notice, whether written notice is required, and whether the policy sets deadlines for proof of claim or legal action.
- Medical documentation: Keep bills, treatment notes, diagnostic results, prescriptions, mileage, work restrictions, and a brief symptom log. Your records should connect treatment to the crash without exaggeration.
- Liability evidence: Preserve the police report, scene photographs, vehicle damage photographs, witness statements, video, and communications with the other driver or insurer.
- Insurer correspondence: Save every letter, email, recorded-statement request, reservation-of-rights letter, coverage position, and settlement proposal. Note response deadlines and the name of the adjuster.
- Legal deadlines: The injury claim statute of limitations and UM/UIM contractual deadlines may differ. Use the relevant state rules and policy language rather than relying on a general online deadline. Our state-by-state claim timeline template can help organize questions for local review.
- Dispute procedures: Look for arbitration, appraisal, mediation, or lawsuit provisions. Arbitration language may address procedure, selection of an arbitrator, costs, and deadlines.
If the claim involves a commercial truck, rideshare vehicle, motorcycle, or multiple injured people, additional policies and evidence may be involved. For example, a rideshare driver’s personal policy and platform-related coverage may depend on the driver’s activity at the time. See this rideshare accident insurance guide for a separate coverage checklist.
Common mistakes
- Accepting a settlement before understanding the release. A signed release may end claims against the responsible driver and sometimes affect related coverage. Read it carefully and ask what claims and parties it covers.
- Assuming your own insurer is automatically on your side. Your UM/UIM insurer may evaluate coverage, liability, damages, and policy conditions. Be accurate, cooperative, and cautious about recorded statements when you do not understand the questions.
- Waiting until treatment ends to give notice. Medical recovery can take time, but notice obligations may begin earlier. Notify the insurer as required and update the claim as information develops.
- Failing to investigate other policies. Check household policies and potentially relevant vehicle, employer, or commercial coverage, while recognizing that applicability depends on the facts and policy language.
- Posting details publicly. Photos, comments, and videos about the crash or recovery can be taken out of context. Keep communications factual and avoid discussing fault or a settlement online.
- Using a settlement calculator as a decision-maker. No general pain-and-suffering calculator can account reliably for policy limits, disputed causation, future care, comparative fault, or state-specific rules.
When to revisit
Return to this checklist whenever a key fact changes: you receive the declarations page, learn the other driver’s limits, obtain a coverage denial, finish a major phase of treatment, receive a settlement proposal, or discover another household or commercial policy. Recheck deadlines before sending a demand, accepting liability insurance proceeds, signing a release, or beginning arbitration.
Because UM and UIM requirements differ by state and can change through legislation or appellate decisions, confirm the current rules with your state insurance department, the policy itself, or a qualified local attorney. An accident attorney comparison and consultation checklist can help you prepare questions about experience, fees, communication, conflicts, and whether the lawyer handles uninsured motorist claims.
Your next practical steps are to create a claim folder, request the complete policy, preserve the crash evidence, notify the appropriate insurer, record medical and financial losses, and calendar every stated deadline. Do not sign a release or accept a settlement you do not understand. If coverage is disputed, injuries are continuing, or the proposed payment may not cover your losses, consider obtaining individualized legal advice before taking the next step.